Key takeaways:
- The ATO is placing greater emphasis on persistent losses
- This is particularly relevant to horse breeders
- Existing horse industry rulings still apply
- A loss-making activity can still be a business
- Profitability prospects are becoming critically important
- The seven business indicators remain the core test
- The real danger is when losses are combined with non-commercial behaviour
For such a contentious topic—particularly for participants in the thoroughbred industry—the wait for updated ATO guidance on whether an activity is a “business” or a “hobby” has certainly been a long one.
The wait is over – updated guidance is now available, albeit in draft form. Last month, the ATO published TR 2026/D2, Income tax: carrying on a business by an individual.
This ruling, I must emphasise, doesn’t just deal with the breeding and/or racing industry, but any type of activity. The underlying business indicators are also not exclusive to individuals. Commercial character, profit-making purpose, repetition, organisation and scale are also relevant to other entities, e.g. Companies, trusts, partnerships etc. Their application can produce different outcomes depending on the entity and the statutory provision involved.
This new draft ruling sets out the indicators the Commissioner considers relevant to determine whether an activity undertaken, as an individual, is a business as opposed to an investment or a hobby. This is an important distinction as the taxation treatment of activities will vary depending on this classification. An income tax “business” can claim tax losses and be GST registered, a “hobby” can’t claim tax losses and, generally, can’t obtain GST registration.
The indicators in this draft ruling are consistent with the indicators set out in Taxation Ruling TR 97/11 which are relevant to determining whether a taxpayer carries on a business of primary production for tax purposes. This draft ruling does not replace the more specific advice provided in TR 97/11 and other rulings on this topic and should be read in conjunction with them.
What is significant about this ruling is that it gives more explicit warnings about persistent, commercially unexplained losses, but both require an overall assessment—not a rule that a particular loss amount or number of loss years means “no business”.
On any objective assessment, it is the ATO giving a warning that recurring losses, without any objective likelihood of profits in the future, will be given more weighting by the ATO in the future in determining if an activity is a business or hobby.
If you wish for me to clarify or expand upon anything mentioned in this article, please do not hesitate to contact me.
End of release.
DISCLAIMER
Any reader intending to apply the information in this article to practical circumstances should independently verify their interpretation and the information’s applicability to their circumstances with an accountant or adviser specialising in this area.
Prepared by:
PAUL CARRAZZO CA, CPA
Partner – Baumgartners
1/35 Cotham Rd, Kew, VIC, 3101
TEL: +61 3 9851 9000
MOB: 0417 549 347
E-mail: p.carrazzo@baumgartners.com.au

